1. Introduction
As we study the Bible, we may encounter passages that appear to disagree with one another. Sometimes, two accounts describe the same event from different perspectives. At other times, a difference may result from the wording, the surrounding context, the audience, or the purpose of the passage.
We should not ignore difficult questions or assume that every apparent difference is automatically a contradiction. Instead, we should examine the passages carefully before reaching a conclusion.
In this lesson, we will learn how to investigate passages that seem difficult to reconcile.
2. Scripture Encourages Careful Study
Proverbs 18:13 (KJV)
“He that answereth a matter before he heareth it, it is folly and shame unto him.”
Explanation
This proverb warns against answering a matter before hearing it fully.
The principle applies to Bible study. If we read only one verse and immediately conclude that it contradicts another passage, we may reach a mistaken conclusion because we have not examined all the relevant information.
Before deciding that two passages disagree, we should read their surrounding verses, identify who is speaking, consider the circumstances, and examine what each passage actually says.
Careful study does not mean forcing two passages to agree regardless of the evidence. It means investigating honestly before deciding whether a genuine difficulty exists.
3. Different Accounts May Emphasize Different Details
Matthew 8:28 (KJV)
“And when he was come to the other side into the country of the Gergesenes, there met him two possessed with devils, coming out of the tombs, exceeding fierce, so that no man might pass by that way.”
Mark 5:2 (KJV)
“And when he was come out of the ship, immediately there met him out of the tombs a man with an unclean spirit,”
Explanation
Matthew describes two men, while Mark focuses on one man in his account.
Mark does not explicitly say that only one man was present. His account focuses on the man he describes.
This example shows why we must read each account carefully before declaring that two passages contradict one another.
The accounts may emphasize different details without necessarily disagreeing about the event itself.
However, we should not assume that every difference between biblical accounts can be explained this way. Each case needs to be examined on its own merits.
4. Context Can Clarify Statements That Seem Difficult
John 16:12 (KJV)
“I have yet many things to say unto you, but ye cannot bear them now.”
Explanation
Jesus spoke these words to His disciples before His crucifixion.
He acknowledged that there were things He still wanted to teach them, but they were not yet ready to bear them.
This verse reminds us that biblical statements were spoken in particular circumstances. Understanding those circumstances helps us recognize what the speaker meant.
When a statement seems difficult to understand, we should examine the surrounding passage and consider the situation being addressed.
We must also avoid using context as an excuse to dismiss clear differences. Context is a tool for understanding, not a reason to ignore evidence.
5. What Should We Do When Two Passages Seem to Disagree?
Acts 17:11 (KJV)
“These were more noble than those in Thessalonica, in that they received the word with all readiness of mind, and searched the scriptures daily, whether those things were so.”
Explanation
The Bereans listened eagerly to the teaching they received, but they also searched the Scriptures daily to examine whether the teaching was correct.
Their example provides a useful method for investigating difficult passages.
When two passages appear to disagree:
-
Read both passages in full.
-
Examine the verses before and after each passage.
-
Identify who is speaking and who is being addressed.
-
Consider whether the passages describe the same event, different events, or different circumstances.
-
Compare the wording carefully.
-
Consult reliable study resources when necessary.
-
Be willing to acknowledge when a question remains unresolved.
This approach helps us avoid rushing to conclusions or accepting explanations simply because they sound convincing.
6. Does Trusting the Bible Mean We Must Ignore Difficult Questions?
No. Trust should encourage careful investigation rather than fear of asking questions.
2 Timothy 2:15 (KJV)
“Study to shew thyself approved unto God, a workman that needeth not to be ashamed, rightly dividing the word of truth.”
Explanation
Paul instructed Timothy to study and handle the word of truth correctly.
This means we should take the work of understanding Scripture seriously.
When we encounter a difficult passage, we should not dismiss it simply because it challenges our existing understanding. Neither should we immediately conclude that the entire Bible is unreliable.
Instead, we should examine the evidence, consider the context, and distinguish between a difficulty we have not yet resolved and a contradiction that has been demonstrated.
A humble student can say, “I do not understand this passage yet,” and continue studying.
Honesty is better than inventing an explanation that the text does not support.
7. Practical Example
Imagine that you read two Gospel accounts describing an event. One account mentions a particular person, while the other account mentions two people.
You may initially think that the accounts disagree.
Instead of reaching an immediate conclusion, you read both passages carefully. You discover that the account mentioning one person does not explicitly state that no one else was present.
You recognize that the difference may reflect the author’s focus rather than a contradiction.
In another situation, you might discover a difference that is more difficult to explain. In that case, you should examine the available evidence rather than forcing a conclusion.
The goal is not to defend every interpretation at any cost. The goal is to understand what the biblical texts actually say.
8. Remember
-
Some biblical passages may appear to disagree when read quickly or without context.
-
Different accounts can emphasize different details.
-
Context helps us understand statements made in particular circumstances.
-
We should investigate difficult passages honestly and carefully.
-
Not every apparent contradiction is a genuine contradiction, but not every difficulty has an immediate explanation.
-
We should be willing to acknowledge uncertainty while continuing to study.
Key takeaway: When Bible passages appear to contradict one another, do not rush to judgment. Examine the wording, context, and available evidence carefully before reaching a conclusion.
Reflection question: When you encounter two Bible passages that seem to disagree, what steps can you take to understand them before deciding what they mean?